Troy v, Iliad

Guidelines for the Comparative analysis of the pic Troy and The Iliad Your comparative search should be typed in single space paragraphing (font 12 Times new-fashioned Roman) and it should be at least 500 denominations. (I will practice session the word count feature in Microsoft Word to check the number of words. ) exploit non to exceed 1000 words at most. Your essay should be the result of your throw contemplations, observations and conclusions. You gouge register other sources for this assignment unspoiled you should not copy at whatever form or to any degree the sources you have read.You fundament just use the ideas gained through sources in your own words. If you do so, however, you should definitely cite the references to your sources. In case you use a source and forget to cite it or even worse if you copy from a source the score for your paper will be zero. So please bewargon of intentional or unintentaional plagiarism. In write up the paper first watch the mo vie comp allowely and if needful take notes. (The DVD of the movie is provided to you. )Then, compare what you have guaranteen with what you have read and try to find out the reasons for the differences.The followinig notes may help you ?Note the changes in value systems in the past and present ?Note the reasons for the changes and passings that have taken place in the creation of the movie. (including commercial, political, value, ) ?Focus on justification exposit for the atrocities and savagery that is depicted as valor and courage in the Iliad. ? explore the contri unlessions (messages) that the two works guide to human culture in their own context.Iliad vs. Troy Movie. Neither Athena with her matchless wisdom, nor Apollo with his talent of prophecy, could foretell that someday Prometheuss fragile creature, human, would become rude in a subdue that not only would turn his back to the gods, but also would misrepresent their presence and effects in the human history. Brisei s Well, then your men did. The cheerfulness god will have his vengeance. Achilles Whats he waiting for? Briseis The right clipping to strike. Achilles His non-Christian priests are dead, and his acolytes a captive.I think your god is afraid of me? Briseis panic-stricken? Apollo is master of the sun, he fears naught. Achilles Where is he? (Troy) The movie Troy, which is an adaptation of marks Iliad, is an obvious twist of it, both historically and literarily. There are numerous differences between them that stub be observed and revealed. Here, I am going to highlight some of inordinate modifications of Homers Iliad in Wolfgang Petersens Troy and, then, try to go beyond the surface to break dance the reasons for such changes.The movie duration is about 163 proceeding and it takes 50 minutes to reach to the starting point of the Iliad. Although there are, also, several rotations of the classical myths events in the first 50 minutes that even an amateur classic mythology endorse r can remark it fallacies, I will not enter that domain. I will just refer to the changes that are in contrary with the Iliad and can be retrieved by the information that Homer presents. For instance, in the Iliad we see that it was genus Pariss doom to go to Sparta and fall in fare with Helen. merely the movie gives no account for the background of the story and the destinations role. Another incident which is not mentioned in the Iliad is Achilless rapid put to death to siege the beach of Troy and invading Apollos temple. The major modification of the Iliad is the absence of Gods in the movie. There is no information about them but some names that elder characters mention and some statues. The only Goddess that we can see in the movie is Thetis, Achilless mother, who is a nymph gibe to the Iliad, half human, half fish.But the director of the movie does not compulsion to put emphasis on the divinity part and although Achilles meets her in the water, ideate her fish part is cle verly avoided by the director. Apollo in the movie is just a wretched God who is not able to avenge the crime that Myrmidons have done to him. In the minute 42 of the story, Achilles beheads Apollos statue. period in the Iliad, Achilles respects Gods and makes sacrifices for them. In another scene, in the minute 29, while Hector is urging Priam, his father, to return Helen to Sparta to avoid a war, Priam tells him not to get at because, Apollo watches over us.Even Agamemnon is no match for the Gods. (Troy) But Hector replies, And how umteen battalions does the Sun God command? (Troy) This is not the only place in the movie that Hector, who is protected and respected by gods in the Iliad and highly believes in them, mocks the gods. It happens again in minute 54 of the movie when the high priest announces that two farmers have seen an eagle with a serpent in its talons, a good sign from Apollo. Hector mocks the priest and saying, you want to plan a strategy based on bird signs? H e concludes from Apollos inability to take vengeance on Achilles for insulting his statue and says, The gods wont squeeze this war for us (Troy). The whole story is in contrary with the Iliad, because it is indicated that the Trojans see that sign while trying to push back the Achaean armament to their ships, and predict it as a bad omen from Zeus who is the possessor of the eagle, though. Moreover, in the Iliad, it is gods war more(prenominal) than humans. It seems that there is an intention beyond these manners of mocking gods by two of the best characters who the audience would love best and sympathize with.First assumption would be that the director of the movie wanted to make a realistic shot of the Iliad. But, after increase in the story, another assumption may be that the director does not believe in Gods or divinity at all and try to inject his view through his best characters and he is doing this cleverly. Almost in the first scene that we see Achilles, when the messe nger son asks if the stories about him is true and if he cannot be killed, Achilles responds, I wouldnt be bothering with the shield then, would I? (Troy) a very logical and clever direction to wipe out tendencies of believing in divinity from audiences mind in the beginning of the story and to appeal the skeptic generation of 21st carbon Another major difference between Iliad and the movie is again in the process of adaptation of the Iliad according to the appetite of the audience. Every Iliad reader can understand in a glance that the honor codes and bravery values of those days is in contrary with todays. The most devouring and slaughtering characters were the most praised heroes of the Iliad.Achilles, Hector, Ajax and Diomede were a few samples of ancient world heroes. But, is it possible to picture those animalistic brutalities inwardly Iliad these days and expect to attract people to pay for watching it? Of seam not Instead, we need to show a sentimental view of our heroes , heroes who turn down war heroes who are sorry for killing people. For instance, Hector while reversive from Sparta provokes Paris who wants to fight with Menelaus and says that, there is nothing glorious about it, nothing poetic (Troy).But it is indeed glorious in the Iliad to fight. In situation Homer calls Hector the pair of bloodthirsty Mars as an honor. On the other hand, we need a kind, loving and caring Achilles with a masculine attractive figure to attract more audience. What about softening the emphasis with some romance scenes to guarantee our investment, no matter what was the story and what was the truth. So, lets dismiss Diomede who is a brutal killer, kill Ajax and Menelaus at the beginning, and sink Aeneas and so many other valiant heroes to make the story more appealing and brief.But, lets picture Agamemnon as he was to make people despise him. So tricky Simply put, it seems that cinematographs own a mightier weapon that Zeuss thunder bolt and Poseidons trident by which have sent myth gods and their offspring to the underworld. But, what if someday, they claim war against Semitic or early religions God? What if they twist the reality and feed that in a colorful tempting way to the people? (As Islamic democracy of Iran does it in regard to Bahai faith). Do the audiences of those movies would accept what is being presented or investigate after the truth?